Deadlocked jury in Cosby trial asks: 'What is reasonable doubt?'

On its fifth day of deliberations, the deadlocked jury in Invoice Cosby’s trial requested the courtroom a loaded query: “What is cheap doubt?”

In all, jurors have requested eleven questions of the courtroom amid forty six hours of deliberations, primarily asking to listen to the proof for a second time. The jury’s continued questions depart open the likelihood that jurors might stay deadlocked and unable to succeed in a unanimous verdict on any of the three counts of aggravated indecent assault that Cosby faces.

CNN - Christine Cornell

Prosecutors say Cosby drugged and sexually assaulted Andrea Constand, the previous director of operations for Temple College’s ladies’s basketball group, at his residence close to Philadelphia in January 2004. Cosby, seventy nine, pleaded not responsible to the fees.

Thursday, jurors informed the courtroom they might not come to a unanimous determination past an inexpensive doubt, which is required in legal instances.

Decide Steven O’Neill requested the jury to return into deliberations for an additional try to succeed in a verdict, an instruction recognized in Pennsylvania because the Spencer Cost. It is a set of directions that asks jurors to re-look at their very own views and opinions, and there’s no restrict to what number of occasions a decide can difficulty it.

If, after additional deliberations, jurors nonetheless can’t attain consensus, the decide can select to declare a mistrial. Protection attorneys have repeatedly requested for Decide O’Neill to declare a mistrial based mostly on the jury’s size of deliberations, however the decide has denied their request.

“I’ll permit this to go so long as this jury needs to proceed to deliberate,” O’Neill stated Friday.

If there’s a mistrial, Cosby wouldn’t be thought-about responsible or not responsible, and prosecutors might select to retry the case with a special set of jurors. Nonetheless, that might symbolize a serious win for Cosby’s group, which has argued that the case by no means ought to have reached courtroom.

The 12-individual jury is made up of 4 white ladies, six white males, one black lady and one black man. They have been bused to Norristown, Pennsylvania, from Allegheny County close to Pittsburgh and have been sequestered in a lodge for the trial.

He stated, she stated

The three costs accuse Cosby of assaulting Constand with out her consent, assaulting her when she was unconscious and assaulting her utilizing medicine to considerably impair her means to consent. If discovered responsible, he might resist 10 years in jail for every cost.

Prosecutors referred to as 12 witnesses, together with Constand, over every week of testimony however…

Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *